Showing posts with label populism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label populism. Show all posts

Sunday, July 14, 2013

Thanks EFF for outlawing code

The EFF has been at the forefront calling cyberweapons "unethical" and "dangerous". As a result of such rhetoric by the EFF and many others, the next NDAA (National Defense Authorization Act for 2014) will likely contain provisions to regulate cyberweapons. The text of the law is at the bottom of this post.

This demonstrates the Orwellian nature of EFF's populism. They don't stand for principle but for popularity. They abandon their principle that the Internet is sovereign when they promoted Net Neutrality. They abandon their principle that code is free speech by suggesting that some code needs to be regulated.

The text of the NDAA, below, calls for the president to implement export controls on code:

 SEC. 946. CONTROL OF THE PROLIFERATION OF CYBER WEAPONS.
(a) Interagency Process for Establishment of Policy- The President shall establish an interagency process to provide for the establishment of an integrated policy to control the proliferation of cyber weapons through unilateral and cooperative export controls, law enforcement activities, financial means, diplomatic engagement, and such other means as the President considers appropriate.
(b) Objectives- The objectives of the interagency process established under subsection (a) shall be as follows:
(1) To identify the types of dangerous software that can and should be controlled through export controls, whether unilaterally or cooperatively with other countries.
(2) To identify the intelligence, law enforcement, and financial sanctions tools that can and should be used to suppress the trade in cyber tools and infrastructure that are or can be used for criminal, terrorist, or military activities while preserving the ability of governments and the private sector to use such tools for legitimate purposes of self-defense.
(3) To establish a statement of principles to control the proliferation of cyber weapons, including principles for controlling the proliferation of cyber weapons that can lead to expanded cooperation and engagement with international partners.
(c) Recommendations- The interagency process established under subsection (a) shall develop, by not later than 270 days after the date of the enactment of this Act, recommendations on means for the control of the proliferation of cyber weapons, including a draft statement of principles and a review of applicable legal authorities.